Patriotic fever ran
high among the young men in Shelby County, Ohio in the early 1860's. Many were rushing to
enlist with their friends, so that together they could help save the union and, perhaps,
be a war hero as well. Over three hundred never returned. Some, like the Elliot brothers
of Dinsmore Township, died heroes' deaths. A much crueler and totally unexpected fate
awaited thirteen Shelby County soldiers. This is their story.
These men enlisted over a period of about one year. The oldest was James
Dodson. He had already served an enlistment with the Benton Cadets, was discharged because
of tuberculoses, and left his Plattsville home to fight again at the age of 36. Thomas
Powell was just 16 when he signed on with the 4th Ohio Cavalry.
Several were good friends. George Ragan, William Borum and George Baldwin all served
together in Company B of the 20th Ohio. Theophilus Ailes left his blacksmithing trade in
Port Jefferson to join the 20th, as did Thomas Duncan. Frances Honnell, also a blacksmith
from Port Jefferson, and Nehemiah Baldwin opted to become horse soldiers. They joined the
9th Ohio Cavalry. Their fate would remain intertwined throughout the war. Levi Bird joined
the 12th Ohio Cavalry. James Morris took up arms with the 14th Missouri Infantry. Alfred Swanders and Joseph Wilkinson
enlisted in the 99th Ohio. All these men would be captured and sent to prisons in the
south. Only Wilkinson would survive.
During the first part of the Civil War, capture meant generally humane
treatment, if the scourge of sickness could be avoided. Prisoner exchanges were common
between the armies. Therefore, perhaps the hopes of James Morris were high when he fell
into enemy hands on July 20, 1863 at Danville, Mississippi. The terrible battle of Chickamauga in September of that year saw
the capture of three county boys in one day: James Dodson, Alfred Swanders and Joseph
Wilkinson. An engagement at Florence, Alabama in April of 1864 resulted in Frances
Honnell, Nehemiah and George Baldwin becoming prisoners. On July 22, 1864 more Shelby
Countians lost their lives than on any other day in the war. That same day the Rebels
captured Thomas Duncan and Theophilus Ailes.
Even though the conditions of
southern prisons would get much worse toward the end of the war, disease claimed several
imprisoned Shelby County men fairly soon after their capture. Swanders died on New Year's
Day, 1864. He was kept at Libby prison in Richmond, Virginia until December 11th, when he
was sent to a Rebel hospital in Danville. His military records list the cause of death as
both "enemy cruelty" and "chronic diarrhea." His
brother, Aaron, would be killed in battle later that year at Kennesaw Mountain, Georgia.
Morris, Honnell, Powell, Ailes, Borum and George and Nehemiah Baldwin were subsequently
transferred to the infamous prison at Andersonville, and all died there by October of
1864. By this time in the war, General U.S. Grant was the Commander of the Union Army. In
late 1864, he ordered a halt to the prisoner exchanges. His motive was to increase the
stranglehold on the Confederacy by cutting off its supply of soldiers. His decision also
sealed the fate of thousands of Union soldiers, for whom there would be no escape.
Included among these men were Thomas Duncan, Levi Bird and George Ragan. Ragan died while
still in prison after the surrender of General Lee at Appomatox.
What untold suffering did
these men experience? We will never know. Their lips are now sealed. Letters from only one
of the men are known to exist. Alfred Swanders wrote to his sister Savilla, who lived on
the family farm south of Anna, on two occasions. On November 20, 1863, Alfred sent a
letter asking for "a shirt, a pair of socks, no. 11 shoes, 20 lbs. of crackers,"
along with paper and stamps. It was not mailed until December 9th, and he died three weeks
later.
One comrade in arms, Joseph Wilkinson, did survive. Many years after the war,
Wilkinson talked to a biographer working for R. Sutton and Co. His story paints a grim
reminder about the tragedies of war and man's inhumanity to his fellow man.
Wilkinson was the youngest of six
brothers. When he enlisted in August of 1862, he was 18. Before the war was concluded, his
parents would grieve over the loss of two sons. William was killed on the battlefield at
Chickamauga on the same day Joseph was captured. George, who was also in company C of the
99th with Joseph, had died earlier at Nashville, Tennessee.
While tending to a wounded comrade,
Joseph was surrounded and captured. After spending a short time in Libby prison, he was
transferred with 5,000 others to Danville and kept throughout the winter in tobacco barns.
Smallpox broke out, and spread in a quick but deadly fashion. Wilkinson contracted it but
recovered. Out of the 22 prisoners from his regiment, 19 died. He remembered: "I
acted as nurse for several weeks in what they called a 'hospital.' It did not deserve the
name, for we had no medicines whatsoever except for red pepper pods, which we boiled and
administered as tea to the sick."
In April of 1864, the survivors were
loaded in box cars and transported 700 miles to the newly opened prison in Andersonville,
Georgia. The trip took 7 days. "None of us were permitted to leave the cars for
any purpose. When we reached Andersonville, a number of dead were found in each car." When asked about it later, Wilkinson would only state, "My experience at
Andersonville is too horrid to relate, and is almost beyond belief." A few
details from the military record will suffice.
Run by Swiss emigrant Henry Wirz,
the prison and its conditions were the cause of the deaths of 13,000 union soldiers in
only 14 months. The prisoners had an average of 6 square feet per person. Death by
starvation and all manner of disease was a daily occurrence. Wirz once boasted that he was "...destroying more Yankee soldiers than General Lee was killing."
One southern lady was allowed to
climb a guard tower and overlook the prison. Her prophetic, yet chilling comment: My
heart aches for those poor wretches, Yankees though they are, and I am afraid God will
suffer some terrible retribution to fall upon us for letting such things happen. If the
Yankees should ever come to south-west Georgia and go to Anderson and see the graves
there, God have mercy on the land.
Wirz was later tried by a military
tribunal led by General Lew Wallace,
convicted, and executed in Washington on November 10, 1865.
According to Rebel records,
by September of 1864, one of every two men entering the prison was dying. Wilkinson felt
lucky when he was transferred during that month to a prison in Florence, South Carolina.
Lucky? If possible, conditions there were worse. "(Our) clothing had become so
ragged and tattered it scarcely covered our nakedness. Mortality thinned our ranks, and
our prison was a charnel house. Rations were reduced. For four months one pint of coarse
corn meal was a daily ration, no salt meat of any kind. The monthly mortality footed up
fifty percent."
Finally, on March 10, 1865 Wilkinson and the other union
survivors were taken to Richmond to be released. The men were threatened by the Rebel
guards against wild rejoicing. Wilkinson remembered the moment vividly: "We were
all sick and weak, but as we came in sight of our flag, we yelled crazily at the top of
our voices. We were in the sight of our men, and could not be restrained."
After 18 months of the most inhumane
captivity imaginable, Wilkinson was free. The scene was one he would never forget. "We
were met by northern ladies, who had provided coffee and sandwiches for our reception. One
of them, she seemed an angel, handed me a cup of coffee....but my stomach revolted at an
article it had not known for a year and a half. She appreciated my difficulty, and uttered
the words: 'Poor fellow!' Those words were the first I heard uttered by a woman from the
time of my capture, and they came like an angel's benediction."
After his return to Sidney in
the early spring of 1864, Joseph Wilkinson slowly adjusted to normal life. he completed
his schooling, taught school and then ran a lumber business. In 1875, Wilkinson married
Mary McKee of Piqua. Two children, Kate and John soon followed. He subsequently was
appointed postmaster of Sidney, a position he held for many years.
[ Back to Civil War Index ] |